Picky Eaters...help! I'm literally throwing away money here.
What about it?
For years our cats would eat nothing but Fancy Feast, which my vet constantly refers to as junk food. When Petco started moving away from mainstream cat food I literally tried all of their new organic bougie brands, alas to no avail. However, now they are starting to turn their noses up with their formally beloved Fancy Feast. Not sure if they changed the recipe or formulation recently, but both cats just lick the gravy off then walk away from the bowl...they will then follow me around the kitchen for the rest of the day like they're starving or something. We also have a dog and I sometimes see them trying to eat her wet food instead of what's in their own bowls.
Can anyone else with SUPER picky eaters recommend something else? We also have a Chewy subscription.